Interrogating the Autonomy of the Judiciary and its Role in Building a Strong National Democracy

Authors

  • Joseph Chibuzo Inmpey PhD General Studies Division Enugu State University Of Science And Technolgy, Enugu, Enugu State. Nigeria

Keywords:

Interrogating, Autonomy, Judiciary, Strong National Democracy.

Abstract

There is no doubt that the judiciary is one of the three arms of government vested with constitutional powers of law interpretation and administration of justice. It is therefore not out of place that the constitution to an extent provided measures to ensure its autonomy or independence so as to enhance separation of powers and checks and balances in governance. It is however worrisome that the autonomy of the judiciary has continued to hang in the balance and at the mercy of the executive arm upon which it has continued to depend on for funding and appointment of judges etc. This has adversely affected the role of the judiciary in building a strong national democracy. The paper interrogated the autonomy of the judiciary and its role in building a strong national democracy. The paper raised a number of pertinent conceptual and theoretical issues of practical implications relating to the theme. The importance and threats to judicial autonomy were unraveled. The paper affirmed that judiciary is the guardian and protector of fundamental human rights as well as the arbiter of disputes among all levels of government. This is why the judiciary ought to be not only autonomous but independent so as to be free to perform its functions without fear or favour. This is the primary goal of separation of powers; to enable the three arms of government to be independent of each other financially and otherwise. The paper made some recommendations for future purposes.

Downloads

Download data is not yet available.

References

Aguda, A. (1992).The Judicial Process and the Third Republic (Lagos: F & A Publishers Limited, 1992) 35-36

Akinkugbes, O. O. (1972). “The Role of Lawyers in Society” in T. O. Elias (Ed,), Law and Social Change in Nigeria (1972) 89 at 93.

American Bar Association (2017). Funding of Judiciary: How budgeting system shapes Justice: A comparative Analysis of three case studies. Washington DC.: ABA Publication.

Budlender, G. (2005). “Transforming the Judiciary: The politics of the Judiciary in a Democratic South Africa” The Alan Paton Memorial Lecture: Pietermaritzburg, 2005, July 25)

Chukkol, K. S. (1995). “Enforcement of Judgment Against Public Officers and Institutions and the Rule of law in I. A. Ayua (ed.), Law, Justice and the Nigerian Society: Essay’s in Honour of Honourable Justice Mohammed Bello (Lagos: NIALS, 1995) 60 at 61

Duru, O. (2009). The Role and Historical Development of the Judiciary in Nigeria. Owerri: Totan Publishers.

Duru, O. W. C. (2003). An Overview of Aspects and Attributes of Judicial Independence in Nigeria, available at: http://ssrn.com/abstract=2142974.

Ehiogie, W.I. (2021). Independence of the judiciary: A recipe for true democracy in Nigeria. The Nation Newspaper, Feb 16, 2021

Gambo, I. T. (2014). Budget and organizational performance: A study of Judiciary in Nigeria, Leadership Newspaper, Thursday 11th July, 2014 pg4.

Gambo, I. T. (2019). Financial Independence of the Judiciaries: a Mirage or a Reality, Being a Paper Presented at the National Workshop for Chief Registrars, Deputy Chief Registrars, Directors and Secretaries of Judicial Service Commissions/Committee. Hold at National Judicial Institute on Wednesday, 4th September, 2019

Ijalaye, D. A. (1991). “The Bench, the Bar and the Rule of Law under the Military Regime in Nigeria” (1991) 1(2) JUS 113 at 115

Karibi-Whyte, A. G. (1987). The Relevance of the Judiciary in the Polity-In Historical Perspective (Lagos: NIALS, 1987) 94.

Muhammed T. L. (2012). Nigeria’s Judiciary and governance: Roles, Functions, and Power. Benin city: Ethiope books Ltd.

Nnaemeka-Agu, P.N. (1993). “Enhancing the Efficacy and Independence of the Judiciary in the Third Republic” (1993) 4 (3) JUS 9 at 18-19.

Obilade, O. (2001). Nigerian Legal System, Ibadan: Spectrum books Ltd.

Ogbu, O. N. (2000). “The Judiciary in a Polity-a force for Stability or Instability: The Nigeria Experience” ABSU Law Journal. 11(5), 25-34.

Oloko, D. (1990). “Independence of the Judiciary with Particular Reference to Appointments; Removal and Discipline” in Y. Osibanjo and A. Kalu (Eds.), Law, Development and Administration in Nigeria (Lagos: Federal Ministry of Justice Law and Review Series, 1990) at 533.

Oputa, C. (1992). “The Ten Commandment for the Judge: Judicial Comportment and Attitudes in the Effective Judicial Enforcement of Rights” (1992) 2(5) JUS 15 at 28.

Oputa, C. A. (1990). “Independence of the Judiciary with Particular Reference to Appointment, Removal and Discipline” in A. Ajibola, Y. Osibanjo and A. Kalu (Eds.), Law, Development and Administration in Nigeria Vol. 1. (Lagos: Federal Ministry of Justice Law Review Series, 1990) 494 at 499.

Oputa, C. A. (2007). “The Judiciary as an Unbiased Umpire in the Democratic Process” in C. Okeke (Ed.) Towards Functional Justice: Seminar Papers of Justice Chukwudifu A. Oputa (Ibadan: Gold Press Ltd.

Oputa, C.A. (1990). “Independence of the Judiciary with Particular Reference to Appointment, Removal and Discipline” in A. Ajibola, Y. Osibanjo and A. Kalu (Eds.), Law, Development and Administration in Nigeria Vol. 1. (Lagos: Federal Ministry of Justice Law Review Series, 1990) 494 at 499.

The 1999 Constitution of the Federal Republic of Nigeria (Amended)

United Nations General Assembly (1985). The United Nations Basic Principles on the Independence of the Judiciary were “endorsed” by the United Nations General Assembly in November 1985

Wikipedia.org (2019). Judicial Autonomy. Accessed online at www.wikipedia.org.

Yakubu, M.G. (1990). “Independence of the Judiciary” in B. Ajibola, Y. Osibanjo and A. Kalu (Eds.), Law Development and Administration in Nigeria Vol. 1 (Lagos: Federal Ministry of Justice Law Review Series, 1990) at 546.

Published

2022-05-10

How to Cite

Joseph Chibuzo Inmpey PhD. (2022). Interrogating the Autonomy of the Judiciary and its Role in Building a Strong National Democracy. American Journal of Economics and Business Management, 5(5), 28–37. Retrieved from https://globalresearchnetwork.us/index.php/ajebm/article/view/1054