The Framework for Amending the 2005 Iraqi Constitution Under the Supervision of the Executive Authority: A Comparative Study
Keywords:
-Abstract
The constitution stands above all legal norms and prevails over them. It serves as the foundation upon which legislators rely in enacting ordinary legal rules. It is the source upon which all authorities are established, and through it, the boundaries and controlling powers of these authorities are defined. However, this supremacy does not imply that its provisions must remain fixed and rigid. Rather, public interest may necessitate constitutional amendments—whether by deletion, modification, or addition to its articles—in response to political, economic, or social developments.
This research addresses the concept of constitutional amendment from the perspective of legal scholars. It also examines the mechanism for amending the 2005 Iraqi Constitution by reviewing the relevant provisions within the constitution itself, with a focus on the role of the executive authority—namely, the President of the Republic and the Prime Minister—in the amendment process.
The study also reviews the most significant general principles governing the constitutional amendment process, including the justifications for amendment and its various types. It further investigates the scope of the executive authority and the procedures it follows in the amendment process.
By placing the rules of constitutional amendment under scrutiny, the research reveals overlapping powers on the one hand, and a lack of clarity on the other, which has led to deviations in the state’s public policy. This, in turn, has significantly affected the independence of the constitutional process. Despite the necessity of constitutional amendments due to contradictions among certain provisions, the amendment process has become nearly impossible amid political conflicts, unless a genuine political will is present.
References
References
First: Constitutions
1. Algerian Constitution of 1976
2. Iraqi Constitution of 1925 (Monarchy Era)
3. Iraqi Constitution of 1970
4. Iraqi Constitution of 2005 (Current)
5. French Constitution of 1946
6. United States Constitution of 1787
Second: Books and Researches
7. Basuni, Abdul Ghani. Al-Waseet fi Al-Nuzum Al-Siyasiyah wa Al-Qanun Al-Dusturi. Vol. 1, Manshat Al-Ma’arif, Alexandria, 2004.
8. Dahamil, Elifeyeh, and Yves Mini. Al-Mu’jam Al-Dusturi. Translated by Mansour Al-Qadi, Al-Mo’assasa Al-Jami’ah lil-Dirasat wa Al-Tawzi’, 1996.
9. Hani, Iman Qasim. “Ta’dil Al-Dustur fi Zill Al-Dustur Al-Iraqi li-’Aam 2005.” Majallat Kulliyat Al-Rafidain Al-Jamia lil-‘Uloom, no. 31, 2013.
10. Hashim, Hamid. Mabadi’ Al-Qanun Al-Dusturi wa Tatwir Al-Nizam Al-Siyasi fi Al-Iraq. Maktabat Al-Sanhuri, Baghdad, 2013.
11. Heikal, Al-Sayyid Khalil. Al-Qanun Al-Dusturi wa Al-Anzima Al-Siyasiyah. Cairo, 1983.
12. Khazaz, Zamil Maher. “Ta’dil Al-Dustur Al-Iraqi Al-Naafidh li-Sanat 2005 Bayn Al-Nazariyah wa Al-Tatbiq.” Majallat Al-Kitab lil-‘Uloom Al-Insaniyah, vol. 6, no. 9, University of Al-Kitab, Kirkuk, 2023.
13. Majid, Muhsin Khalil. Al-Nuzum Al-Siyasiyah wa Al-Dustur Al-Lubnani. Dar Al-Nahda Al-‘Arabiyya, Beirut, 1979.
14. Mazhar Awad Al-Shammari, Mazen. “Ta’dil Al-Dustur Al-Iraqi Al-Naafidh li-‘Aam 2005.” Majallat Kulliyat Al-Qanun lil-‘Uloom Al-Qanuniyyah wa Al-Siyāsiyyah, vol. 11, no. 43, 2022.
15. Mohammed, Hussein. Al-Wajeez fi Nazariyat Al-Qanun Al-Wadi’ Al-Jaza’iri. Algeria, 1986.
16. Mohammed Rafat Abdul Wahab. Al-Qanun Al-Dusturi. Al-Dar Al-Jami’iyya, Alexandria, no date.
17. Mufriji, Ehsan Hamid, and Katran Zgheer, Raghad Naji. Al-Nadhariyah Al-‘Ammah fi Al-Qanun Al-Dusturi wa Al-Nuzum Al-Siyasiyyah fi Al-Iraq. Baghdad, 1990.
18. Sa’d, Asfour. Al-Qanun Al-Dusturi. Dar Al-Ma’arif, Alexandria, 1954.
19. Sabri, Al-Sayyid. Mabadi’ Al-Qanun Al-Dusturi. Al-Matba’ah Al-‘Alamiyyah, Cairo, 1949.
20. Shawi, Munther. Falsafat Al-Dawlah. Al-Dhakirah lil-Nashr wa Al-Tawzi’, Baghdad, 2013.
21. Sarour, Ahmad Fathi. Manhaj Al-Islah Al-Dusturi. Dar Al-Nahda Al-‘Arabiyya, Cairo, 2006.
22. Skaini, Hussein Ghalib. Al-Mawdu’at Al-Khilafiyyah fi Al-Dustur Al-Iraqi. Al-Ghadeer Printing, Basra, 2008.
23. Yousif, Ali. Mabadi’ Al-Qanun Al-Dusturi wa Al-Nuzum Al-Siyasiyyah. Dar Itrak lil-Tiba’ah wa Al-Nashr wa Al-Tawzi’, Cairo, 2004.
24. Hamza, Ali Mohsen. Al-Ijra’at Al-Shakhlia wa Al-Mawdu’iyyah li-Ta’dil Al-Dustur Al-Iraqi li-Sanat 2005. Dar Al-Ruwad Al-Muzdahira, Baghdad, 2014.
25. Jabar Ali Abdullah Jamal Al-Din. “Al-Ijra’at Al-Kafila bi-Ta’dil Al-Dustur Al-Iraqi li-Sanat 2005.” Majallat Al-Ma’had, Al-Ma’had Al-‘Alamin, no. 5, 2021.
26. Hasan Mustafa Al-Bahri. “Hudud Ta’dil Al-Dustur wa Atharuh ‘Ala Al-Sultatain Al-Tashri’iyya wa Al-Tanfidhiyya.” Majallat Al-Ma’had, no. 9, Al-Ma’had Al-‘Alamin, 2022.
